Tuesday, 9 March 2021

Unit 1: LO4 - ???

Difference Between Ethical & Legal Issues:

- Legal issues are covered by law, e.g how a media product will exist, where it exists, etc.
- For ethical issues, there may be no legal issues, but it'll cause moral controversy. 


Two schools of thought:

- Hypodermic syringe (Theodore Adorno, 1930s) - media has a negative impact, mass audiences believe everything they see/hear.

Issues about violence?
Issues about sexual content?
Issues about representation?
Positive impact / role models?

Other school of thought:

We are able to filter and adapt to content in media (Gauntlett). We have uses and gratifications theory - people use internet for their own purposes.


 Knives Out - Mystery / Comedy.


Hypodermic Syringe: Issues or Advantages?

Positives: 

- Shows a positive light on immigrants; Marta the nurse, the main protagonist, is an immigrant. Her mother is undocumented, yet the victim in the story (who is shown throughout to be a good man that wanted to expose the bad in his family) chose to 'sacrifice' himself and stop Marta from calling help for him. This was so that her family would be protected from scrunity. Therefore, if the audience followed the hypodermic syringe theory, they would view her and the immigrant family as good (and perhaps superior to the the greedy rich family).

- It sends a positive message to the audience; never cheat, lie, or cause pain for your own wishes or gain; karma will come to you eventually, even if the 'threat' is killed.

- It challenges socially unacceptable views.

Negatives:

- There are quite distressing scenes. For example, someone is 'poisoned' and found by the protagonist while they are dying - spiders crawl over their body. Another moment is at the end of the film, where the main antagonist appears to nearly stab the protagonist with a knife, though it turns out to be fake. Even more, there was a scene of the victim cutting his throat in order to commit suicide right at the beginning, and the blood sprays out from what the protagonist sees.

- The movie casts a harsh light on the rich family, meaning that the audience could view all of the rich in a negative light as a result. Though this is an important part of a movie, to criticise the upper class, so this may not be a fair point to judge on.


Representation:

All representations are mediated (Hall, 1980).

Is there use of stereotypes / countertypes (plays the exact opposite of their stereotypes) - (Perkins, 1979). Not all stereotypes are negative.

Representation of women - are they objectified (Mulvey, 1975). Representation of men (Earp and Katz, 1999) - 'equation of masculinity with pathological control and violence'.

Representation of gay people (Butler, 1993) - are stereotypical.

Alvarado (1987) - ethnicity 'exotic, dangerous, humorous, pitied'

Ethical - offensive material? Sensationalism? Censorship - has the film been censored? 





No comments:

Post a Comment

Unit 1: Key Organisations & Target Audience

Key Organisations: The Published Audience Measurement Company (formally the NRS) (online publishing and print publishing media) ( PAMC ) Bro...