Tuesday, 9 March 2021

Unit 1: Ethical Impact of Media Products

 Ethics VS. Law

Something illegal is clear, it is an action which breaks the law.

Ethics are more unclear, they are based on moral and personal codes. Therefore showing something to be unethical is much more difficult.


Research:

Nestle's contribution of formula milk to international aid.

Nestle forced third world mothers to rely on their instant baby formula, which caused great controversy as this reliance caused the deaths of infants when their mothers couldn't get hold of their product. Their formula was dubbed 'The Baby Killer' by social rights groups, who in the early 1970s, showed the unethical practices that Nestle were taking part in for profit. 


The New Internationalist claimed that Nestle caused this in three ways:
- Creating a need for the formula where none existed.

- They convinced customers that the product was indispensable.

- Linking the products with positive yet unattainable connotations, then giving free samples.

Mothers stop producing milk once their child stops feeding. Therefore, once Nestle started forcing people to pay for the product, mother's couldn't feed the babies themselves; which caused mass infant mortality. Or, the formula was mixed with too much water, which left the babies with severe malnutrition. This may have not been illegal in the eyes of the law, but it was highly unethical. 

Whereas the Nestle scandal was very clearly unethical, media and ethics can be harder to pinpoint. The creation of news articles, TV shows, even films can be questioned in terms of ethical value.


Chris Morris' - Four Lions - 2010

> Four Lions in Production

> Protests due to rumours (started by trolls on the internet / offensive to Muslims / Chris Morris screened the film to Muslim High Council of Great Britain)

> Four Lions was released

> Calls to boycott the movie (most protesters were in the white middle class / the focus on the film was male ineptitude, not about Muslims)


News International - Phone Hacking Scandal

In 2011 it came to light that various Murdoch owned newspapers had regularly 'hacked' the voicemail of celebrities and people in the public eye to get information for stories.

This included the voicemail of murdered teenager Milly Dowler - where the deletion of messages was seen by the police as an indication she was still alive. The practice was known to be widespread in tabloid journalism, 'an ethical gray area'.

Phone hacking was always illegal as it fell under Data Protection Act.

The News of the World went under as a result and various staff were charged and imprisoned (Piers Morgan got away with it).

The effect on the audiences trust and views of news outlets would be negative, as the behavior is highly unethical and causes the news to be fabricated.


How can the ethical and legal actions of a media producer affect the success of a media product and its audience demographic?

If a media producers take part in very unethical actions, they can risk destroying their public perception; audiences with morals that are disgusted by the actions will start boycotting or avoiding the product at all cost, like a film or newspaper, and may call for others to do the same. This can cause a mass loss of profit for the company, and may be difficult to recover from until the audience slowly begin to forget their actions. If they cannot survive the initial wave of loss, they will go under. Other problems that can effect a business involving ethics is employee moral; they may feel discouraged and less willing to work with the company, causing their future products to miss usual standards and cause an even greater spiral of reputation ruin for them. Another problem, that could turn into a legal one depending on the situation, is the company maximising profits over employee health. Companies like Disney will layoff their staff if they're aiming to gain more money, or cut pay and force employees to work at less than they deserve. This can absolutely ruin moral in the company, as no matter how much effort they put in, they'll never be properly rewarded (causing the belief that putting in efforts in their products won't mean anything for them, so 'there's no point in trying').

On the other hand, if media producers take part in illegal actions and are caught, they'll lose their company at the hands of the law. If the producers avoid conviction and justice, like in the case of Piers Morgan, they'll lose their jobs or will be seen in a negative light by the audience. Their new shows or products can also be boycotted and fail. In the case of News of the World, they were involved in an awful phone hacking scandal in which they hacked the phone of a deceased missing girl, Milly Dowler. This caused the police to believe that she was alive as some messages were deleted; when the hacking was discovered, due to the Data Protection Act, the newspaper went under and multiple people were charged or imprisoned. Such a scandal being allowed to occur such as this breaks the audience's trust in newspaper outlets, as they wouldn't know if the stories they see are either real or fake. It also falls into a moral grey area for them, as most people wouldn't want to support a company that's bringing harm or confusion to others; breaching privacy also feels very personal, as the audience would want to keep their identities and life away from the public eye, so the idea of companies being able to pay others to hack into their phones would be a terrifying thought. So, the trust in newspaper outlets would dwindle spectacularly if these problematic incidents were to repeat. These opinions would especially hit hard for a newspaper's boss that owns multiple businesses, like Murdoch, as the audience would lose faith in such a person and refuse to trust their other products / outlets / etc as a result.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Unit 1: Key Organisations & Target Audience

Key Organisations: The Published Audience Measurement Company (formally the NRS) (online publishing and print publishing media) ( PAMC ) Bro...