Wednesday, 2 December 2020

Controversy Homework - 03/12/2020




Film
TV show
Video game

That each have been banned/ cause controversy / offence/ been in the news. Your examples must have happened in the last 5-7 years




Film: Cuties

Crime: Cuties was a French film that was released in 2020 - it was focused on being a 'coming of age' artistic piece, aimed towards exposing the exploitation and sexualisation of children. However, it caused a huge surge of controversy immediately upon Netflix's release of the poster; the film had become the very thing it was originally meant to combat against.

The poster itself showed the main character and the other three supporting characters, all of them being children, in revealing outfits and uncomfortable poses. This sparked anger among communities as it blatantly sexualised the children - it was claimed that it was an terribly inaccurate representation of the film, and Netflix changed the poster to something that 'fit the film' and was 'accurate'.
The film's actual release in cinemas and on Netflix caused another wave of controversy. In order to show that children were sexualised and that this was an issue in society, the director Maïmouna Doucouré ended up using shock and sexualisation to try proving this - defeating the purpose of the film entirely.
The parental guide on IMDb further proves this, as people can check to see the warnings to see what unsuitable content might be in the film. Reading the warnings sparked outrage on its own, and despite critics giving it more positive reviews, audiences who checked the films themselves said it was highly inappropriate and that such a film shouldn't have ever been published.
After a mass set of account cancellations, Netflix eventually pulled the film.




TV Show: Supernatural

Crime: As Supernatural, a long-term running TV series with 15 seasons came to a close, it reignited a few controversies of it's own.

For a long amount of time, Supernatural has been accused of queerbaiting - fans believed that the writers were using the relationship of two of the characters to keep them, especially LGBT+ audiences, watching to see if it would develop further. Queerbaiting teases a romantic dynamic (typically for humour), but it doesn't fully commit to LGBT+ representations.

Unfortunately, when the writers did finally write the supporting character Castiel confessing to Dean, he was killed off in the same episode. Audiences were understandably outraged that the writers kept using their relationship for such a long amount of time to then cut it away, and that they didn't need to do such a thing; the translations of the scene in different languages also appeared to differ.

What the writers had done is the 'bury-your-gay' trope. When a character is LGBT+, writers may see them as more expendable than their cisgender heterosexual counterparts, therefore meaning that they're much more likely to die or be left abandoned in the plot.

The outrage was large enough to leave Supernatural trending on social media like Twitter, with many fans both new and old discussing about how immoral it was for such a thing to happen.




Video Game: DDLC

Crime: Doki Doki Literature Club (abbreviated to DDLC) is an anime visual novel, where you play as a high schooler that joins a poetry club under request of your best friend, Sayori. Unlike most visual novels of it's style (due to DDLC appearing like a cutesy and cheerful dating simulator), DDLC is also a horror game.When the game is opened, it warns that the game isn't for children or those that are easily disturbed - this is shown for good reason, as depictions of depression, psychological horror, suicide and heavy topics come up in the later half of the game.

Despite this, the game treats the topics quite carefully, and it quickly rose to fame.

It's heavy topics were bound to cause controversy due to it's popularity - especially when tragically, a suicide of a 15 year old school boy was linked to the game. Multiple news outlets reported on the incident, pointing fingers at the game due to the victim being reportedly 'obsessed' with it. The reporting also caused schools to ban DDLC and to warn parents of letting their children play it.

This caused quite a divide for the game; some say that it was hyperbole to try linking someone's suicide to just the game, and that their home/school environment and other factors should be taken into account. On the other hand, media and public assumption thought that the game must have influenced this, and that it could cause harm to others.

To this day, Doki Doki Literature Club is still available to play, and it appears that the controversy didn't ruin it's reputation.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Unit 1: Key Organisations & Target Audience

Key Organisations: The Published Audience Measurement Company (formally the NRS) (online publishing and print publishing media) ( PAMC ) Bro...